Supergoop vs Elta MD – Which Sunscreen is best ?

Protecting your skin on a daily basis is a must, and what better way to do that than to invest in a great sunscreen? When it comes to choosing sun lotion, Supergoop and Elta MD are two of the biggest names, but which one is better? Supergoop! is the better choice if you have a smaller budget but would like more choice of different sun lotions. In comparison, Elta MD is more luxurious, offers great results, and provides more than just sunscreen, with formulas aimed at helping solve different skin conditions as well as offering broad spectrum sun lotions.

To fully understand the difference between these brands, see some of their best lotions and decide which one is right for your daily skin regimen, read on.

Supergoop! vs Elta MD

Supergoop! and Elta MD are both loved brands with fantastic cult followings. They are primarily discussed within the sunscreen niche of the beauty industry, though they sell a couple of other products not related to sunscreen. Supergoop are a more fun and family friendly brand. Supergoop products look like your everyday supermarket sunscreen whereas Elta MD sell more sophisticated looking sunscreens produced by a company who sold skincare products to hospitals for many years. But don’t be fooled by Supergoops more casual packaging, their sunscreen are legit and not cheap either.

There are a few things to consider when choosing a sunscreen. First, you need to make sure the SPF is high enough to protect you from the sun’s harmful UV rays. Second, you need to choose a sunscreen that is water-resistant so it won’t come off when you sweat or swim. Third, you need to make sure the sunscreen you choose is non-comedogenic, meaning it won’t clog your pores.

Supergoop! Overview

Supergoop! has made it their goal to make sunscreen more comfortable and attractive. Historically, sunscreen provides skin protection, and nothing else. The sun protection often results in uncomfortable skin, greasy-looking faces, and overall unappealing results.  

In order to change the game, Supergoop! created sunscreens that are comfortable and attractive enough to wear on a daily basis. They have over 40 sunscreen products and formulas so that you can find a sunscreen that matches your skin type. Whether you have dry skin or oily skin, go makeup-free or wear makeup religiously, Supergoop! has a product for you.

Supergoop unseen sunscreen

Supergoop! Unseen Sunscreen, 1.7 oz - SPF 40 PA+++ Reef-Friendly, Broad Spectrum Face Sunscreen & Makeup Primer - Weightless, Invisible, Oil Free & Scent Free - Beard Friendly - For All Skin Types

Click image above to view on Amazon

Supergoop unseen sunscreen is my favourite Supergoop sunscreen! It’s almost completely invisible and doesn’t leave any white residue. The formula is water-resistant so I don’t have to worry about reapplying it as often and I can swim knowing I have some sun protection. I have sensitive skin and this doesn’t irritate it at all. Plus, it works great under makeup. I recommend this sun lotion because the formula is so light. It’s not reef safe though, so if you are swimming near a coral reef don’t use this lotion.

Product Lineup

The Supergoop! product lineup is entirely related to sunscreen. The brand provides sunscreen for your face and body. They also provide products with sunscreens included, such as oils, makeup, and moisturizer.

Even though the product lineup is exclusively about skin protection, it has one of the most extensive sunscreen options. No matter what your style or skin needs are, Supergoop! has options for you. The site even has a convenient skin type quiz to help you determine what product is best for your needs.

Price

Supergoop! is a bit pricey. It is more expensive than sunscreens you will find at the local supermarket, but it isn’t necessarily a luxury brand. Though you might need to splurge a bit on this product, you don’t have to spend an arm and a leg on it either.

Customer Reviews

Supergoop! has a cult following, and with good reason. Its extensive product lineup means that those who historically cannot wear sunscreen find something for them. Especially for people with skin sensitivities and excessive dryness, Supergoop! is one of the only brands for them. When customers complain about Supergoop products it’s usually because they are allergic to some of the ingredients, they feel the formula is too shiny or they don’t experience much water resistance and they burn easier than they expected to in water.

Elta MD Overview

Elta MD is another popular skincare brand that is primarily known for its suncare products. The brand aims to provide products that both heal and protect your skin for a beautiful finish. They offer extensive suncare, skincare, and body care products. Elta MD began selling their skin products to hospitals and other medical facilities with a focus on burn departments. With a background in the medical industry delta MD have focused a lot on making products that are good for even the most sensitive skin.

EltaMD UV Clear Facial Sunscreen 

EltaMD UV Clear SPF 46 Face Sunscreen, Broad Spectrum Sunscreen for Sensitive Skin and Acne-Prone Skin, Oil-Free Mineral-Based Sunscreen Lotion with Zinc Oxide, Dermatologist Recommended, 1.7 oz Pump

Click sunscreen image above to view on Amazon

I couldn’t write an article about ELTA MD without including their UV clear sunscreen. I’ve heard many stories of friends being recommended this sunscreen by dermatologists and while doing some research I found this sun lotion to be one of the most highly recommended and talked about lotions online. There are a lot of customer reviews on my online stores and customers rave about the high coverage and non greasy formula that also has no scent and can soak into your skin quickly, even though it may leave your skin dry slightly whiter than before.

Product Lineup

The lineup for Elta MD is much broader than Supergoop! The most popular products are different types of sunscreen. They have facial sunscreen and body sunscreen for many skin types and age groups. This sunscreen lineup is especially popular in Europe, but it is highly popular in America too.

Elta MD provides other skincare products not related to suncare. For example, they offer cleansers, moisturizers, treatments, and specialized products to target acne and aging. In other words, Elta MD’s product lineup has something for every step in your skincare routine.

If you want to find sun protection for acne prone sensitive skin then the UV clear line offer high brand spectrum UV46 protection creams that are gentle on your skin. If you have normal, dry skin or want an anti-ageing sun lotion then the brands UV daily range is a good choice for you.

Price

Elta MD is a bit pricey, but it isn’t outrageous. Some of their products are a bit more affordable than Supergoop!, but it falls in the medium-tier group in terms of price, just like Supergoop! It isn’t a luxury brand, but it isn’t super cheap either.

Customer Reviews

Elta MD is loved because of its simplicity and straight-to-the-point nature. Customers rave about how effective these products are without being over the top and irritating the skin. Instead, they simply heal and protect your skin, which is exactly what their customers want. Elta MD clearly know how to create safe skincare products. However, their sun lotions often leave white marks on your skin. This is because of their highly protective formulas that are usually much whiter than Supergoops more lightweight lotions.

Our Verdict

If you are looking for a product to protect your skin, both Supergoop! and Elta MD have fantastic options. Both of these brands are highly effective and are loaded with healthy and ethical ingredients. In other words, you can’t go wrong with either brand.

To make your final selection, we recommend considering your past experience with sunscreen and your budget. If you cannot find a sunscreen that feels comfortable on your skin, go with Supergoop! However, select Elta MD if you want dermatologist approved lotions created by a brand with a lot of experience in medical departments helping people with skin conditions.

Final Thoughts

Supergoop! and Elta MD are top sunscreen brands, and it’s not hard to understand why. They both offer fantastic products that will protect and heal your skin. Get Supergoop! if you want something more comfortable and specific for your everyday life, and if you prefer lightweight formulas. If you are looking for the ultimate protection, medically approved formulas and are willing to pay the price than ELTA MD offer some amazing sunscreens.

No matter what brand you select, remember to wear sunscreen every day to keep your skin safe from the sun.

Leave a Comment